国外标准分享ASTM F1500000412018

ITEM18The RegulationsGoverning ASTMTechnical CommitteeOperations providefor actionsonnegative votesto beconducted eitherat ameeting orby ballot.This isa ballotto findanegative not persuasive/not relatedor upholdthe actionof thesubcommittee.Before voting,please beclear asto whatyour votemeans.AFFIRMATIVE-Indicates thatyou SUPPORTTHE ACTIONin rulingthenegative vote notpersuasive/not relatedand thatyou DONOT AGREEWITHTHE NEGATIVE VOTERNEGATIVE-Indicates thatyou DISAGREEin rulingthe negativevote notpersuasive/not relatedand thatyou AGREEWITH THENEGATIVEVOTER.Negative votesdo notinclude awritten statement.ABSTAIN-indicates thatyou do not wishto voteto agreeor notagree withthetask groupin rulingthe negativevotenotpersuasive/not related.It ispreferable toabstainif youhave nointerest inthe ballotitem.Background orsummary onballot history:WK35919appeared onBallot F1512・01as item#4Reapproval ofF2286-2005Design andPerformance Specificationfor RemovableMesh Fencingfor SwimmingPools,Hot Tubs,and SpasToview theoriginal ballotitem,go tothe“My Ballots“section ofthe website,under“Closed Ballotsand ClosingReports“section.Negative Voter:Robert Rung,Hayward PoolProds,Inc.Negative Comment:Section

4.3:Some springsare notadequate toactivate latchin a wind.Add・selflatching.♦一against a20mph wind,accommodate....

5.

2.152lb does not equal73kg.Is eithercorrectNon PersuasiveRationale:Committee findsthis requirementto benon-persuasive forthe followingreasons:

1.There isno factualrational forawindspeed of20mph.

2.Risk analysisdoesnotrecognize windas ahazard.

3.Other standardsand coderegulations onlyaddress thatthe gateshould openout fromthepool anddonotaddress windas ahazard.。